), You can buy a cheap chinese one off amazon for 20% of the cost and get all the same Info, I think smart scales are a terrible place to spend a premium (I say that as someone who did once with a Fitbit aria, which cost 10x more than any scale I had bought before and was the biggest piece of crap Ive ever used, threw it out a few months ago). Now after several years of it being released, have things gotten better? After more than 1,000 total weigh-ins on 12 smart scales, we recommend the reliable Greater Goods WiFi Smart Body Composition Scale. A community for discussing Garmin hardware, software and services. At 149 it is a bit expensive for a scale but for the features and easy usability its tough to argue its worth it. Iâm entirely within the Garmin ecosystem (Forerunner, Edge, Vivofit) so it made sense for me to buy the scale. Then, one day, I started to think about it. I have had to setup/reconnect it each and every time. I love it except for that. Garmin has launched a new smart scale, the Garmin Index S2, which will sync with your Garmin Connect account over Wi-Fi, allowing you to track your … Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and ANT+ syncing. The scale automatically recognizes which of us is on the scale. It sports an attractive design, gathers more information than any other scale and presents the data in an easy-to-understand app. Please offer your opinions, hopefully based on actual use. Since I already use other products in the Garmin family I was willing to pay a little more even though there are much less expensive options out there. There's large thread about this on the garmin forums. Ours works like it's supposed to. Does it give any extra info in Connect? I don’t do many product reviews, but after picking up the Garmin Index Smart Scale on Prime Day and using it for a few months, I thought other runners would like to hear my thoughts on the scale and how I’m using it. The Garmin Index Smart Scale is available in black or white. Scale Failed after 6 Weeks - Returning for Warranty Service, I'm responsible for $20 Shipping Fee to Garmin, Reviewed in the United States on June 4, 2017, Reviewed in the United States on March 29, 2019. Once set up it reliably recognizes who's on it (25kg difference though) and synchronizes with Garmin Connect. I can track my weight and some extra readings in garmin connect easily. This bug has been around for well over a year and no fix in sight from Garmin yet. Best buy Associate explained and set up everything that was possible for me. When we asked Garmin about this issue, a … My husband and I both have Garmin watches which we use as step trackers, for running, and recording strength workouts. 8 best smart bathrooms scales that do more than just weigh. Supposedly, it has WiFi issues, where it would be a serious hassle to connect it, and even if it is working sometimes it will just disconnect itself. At $150, it costs the same as the top two scales in our ranking, the QardioBase and the Withings WS-50. Nope. To start, I am an avid Garmin customer. I really want this to get my vitals into connect (and no, I don't want to sync across other services) but I worry there's a new version around the corner. Nice new product, improvement beyond basics needed, Reviewed in the United States on January 24, 2016. Bottom line is, it works great and synchs flawlessly with Garmin connect. Reviewed in the United States on August 4, 2018. But the software associated with this Garmin product still has some kinks to work out. I had it in stones! Question: Will the Withings Body+ scale pass ALL the data to (and through) MyFitnessPal? This is odd but useable. Hit reset button in back of scale. I've noticed big differences when I toggle the mode on my withings scale. I use my phone hotspot (wifi) as a connection. (I also own a Garmin Stupid Watch - no connection issue - just bad data collection), Reviewed in the United States on January 18, 2020. I have an Edge with HR strap and got a Forerunner lately. Completely clear app from phone (otherwise it will just hang on the connect attempt), reboot up app, attempt connection again. Some places in the world the connection to the garmin ntp server is really bad. I have the black version, even though it’s more of dark blue in my opinion. I am happy that the numbers are fairly close, day after day, and when there's any jump, I can usually explain/justify it based on eating or exercise patterns. I use it daily. My router is a Google mesh. CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON. I picked this scale up the day it was released. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Reviewed in the United States on June 23, 2019, Initial setup went fine. I have 2 different ones and had to return both. I am especially interested in having all the statistics in Garmin Connect and MyFitnessPal. The Best Smart Bathroom Scales for 2020. We all know FitBit and … The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Supposedly Garmin has a new scale “coming soon.” I’ve gone through 3 scales before finally breaking down and buying the garmin one and have been very happy. The Garmin Smart scale setup requires wifi and bluetooth and connects with either the pc (via an extra usb extension) or to the Connect mobile app. Garmin Index is Wi-Fi connected, allowing you to wirelessly sync your data to our free Garmin Connect online fitness community. The scale is 35 x 31 x 3 cm and weighs 2,8 kg making it a robust, solid scale. I weigh 16 stones. Any rumours about a new version of the scale? Clean design. Which is the reason I bought a Garmin "smart" scale, so all of my metrics would be automatically uploaded to the app. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Set Up Garmin Index Smart Scale. I realize this is a somewhat precise scenario, but I think it applies to other folks situations, as well. Many of us keep track of our steps and daily activity with our fitness trackers. The wifi issues mainly occur because of the ntp (time) server the scale uses. Really disappointing. I believe the weight is fairly accurate. The scale looks great and feels like quality hardware. As far as set-up goes, if you have a Garmin ant+ USB/s and today, Garmin is launching the Index S2 which builds upon the success of the original with a new high resolution color display and a slimmer profile.. Before we get into it, if you’d prefer to watch a video version of this review, you can view that below: Could be very useful, but cannot set up and Garmin support is totally useless. I have the withings body+ and use smart scale sync to get the data into Garmin connect. The ONLY time it connects properly is when my phone is connected to a different Wifi and is sharing it via the hotspot. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Garmin Index Smart Scale, Black at Amazon.com. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Garmin Index Smart Scale with Connected Features - Measures Weight, Body Mass Index, Body Fat, Muscle Mass and More - Black at Amazon.com. It claims to be able to measure your weight, body mass index, body composition (including fat … The directions could have been better for adding the second user, but we eventually figured it out. Supports up to 16 users. But I also heard that since Nokia bought the company it was a total mess. I will say that I'm the only one in the house using it, so I'm not commenting on its ability to recognize different users properly. I liked the idea of being able to have my data with weight, body fat %, skeletal muscle mass and water hydration % (so many stats!) It's a bit off topic, but you may have an answer for me. Does it also send the data to MyFitnessPal without problem? See More Reviews. The Garmin Index Smart Scale is on the high end of the price range for scales that wirelessly and automatically sync your weigh-ins to an app. I was really about to buy the Index scale some time ago, but a friend who works at Garmin told me they were having a lot of issues with it and he would recommend me waiting until those are sorted out. That data being my weight, as there is no option to manually enter the other metrics. It is a bit ridiculous you have to fiddle with these things for a product like this to get it working properly though. It provides all the necessary information to monitor progress and track results. When you factor in the trends with all of the different metrics on Garmin connect, it was a really phenomenal amount of data to analyze over time. Syncs immediately. I decided to try this scale to track weight and body fat. There are two main criticisms that I have. I have been a long-time Garmin user and an endurance athlete for 20+ years. I kinda liked it better when I could say 16 stones. Full disclosure: I’m a bit of a bargain shopper and picked this up on sale for $99 (normally $150). I turned it upside down, flipped the switch and there it was. Pounds! Since the initial setup. The device measures weight (in pounds, kilograms or stones), body mass index (BMI), body fat/water content, bone mass, and … It was also awesome because I have a slew of Garmin devices that I use to record my actual workouts so I could go to one spot to really look at my fitness from a big picture standpoint. (Does it do what it is supposed to do), or is it confirmed that it is not worth the hassle? It works great! thanks for this, just subbed. A welcome addition to Garmin's massive range of running watches and wearables, the Index Scales are the most likely here to satisfy fitness fiends. At this point I would 100% not recommend buying one. Garmin and MFP usually sync ok, but once in awhile they have issues. - as long as you use Garmin Connect as your main health tracker, Reviewed in the United States on October 14, 2017. I have tried factory resetting the scale as well. I have mine for 2,5 month, use it with two persons. Works seamlessly. I bought the garmin scale in 2018. Etc...etc...etc... Once the Wifi is saved to he scale, you shouldn't have to go through this process EACH AND EVERY TIME. I've had mine for a few years now, in the early days it did have some WiFi issues but these were mostly resolved in later firmware versions.I would recommend them for someone in the Garmin infrastructure. The initial set up was a little frustrating. I had no problems setting up the Wifi and Bluetooth connectivity for myself, as well as linking my wife's Garmin Connect profile. If the scale cannot connect to the garmin ntp server it will not sync data. Also, I have read that occasionally it wouldn't send the full data to Garmin Connect, or even it wouldn't send the weight to MFP. When I bought this product back in June 2017 it worked great. Garmin supplied Android Authority with the Garmin Index … No problems at all since then. Prior to Jan 13th 2018, I would've recommended this scale very highly. About this Garmin Index S2 smart scale review: I used the Garmin Index S2 for nine days. © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, 1,300 global ratings | 795 global reviews, Great product but you're at the mercy of the Garmin Connect app's engineers as to how consistently it records data, Reviewed in the United States on February 1, 2018. The glass topping and round edges give it a stylish look. Always wanted to get my data into Garmin. This new model switches to a color display that’ll show weight trending information, helping … It worked "as designed" right out of the box -- no wifi issues for me. From. Mine suffers from the bug where body fat% is stuck at 7%, the weight tracking works but paying Â£130 for a scale is madness. I am very surprised that companies don't seem to be more interested in making a really good product for this sector :/. I read a lot on reviews on this scale before getting it, and I was afraid I'd want to send it back. are you comparing DEXA to Nokia's "athlete mode" or was your scale set in normal mode? However, the Index S2 experience could have been improved by a better design and onboarding process. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Garmin Index Smart Scale, Wi-Fi Digital Scale, Recognizes Up to 16 Users, Up to 9 Months of Battery Life, Black at Amazon.com. Or you do not use MFP? What the heck? Overall Review Of The Garmin Index Smart Scale The Garmin Index Smart Scale is one of the best smart scales out there, and our final take is overwhelmingly positive. The Garmin Index Smart Scale is on the high end of the price range for scales that wirelessly and automatically sync your weigh-ins to an app. Price-wise, a little steep for what you get, I'd wait until the price drops. Get Connected. The Garmin - Index Smart Scale - Black is the Best Smart Scale, Best Price at Best Buy. The Garmin Index Smart Scale, as the price suggests, is more than just a bathroom scale. Connect fails. Highly recommend for those already in the Garmin world! Garmin Index Smart Scale. I did a work-a-round by adding a dns entry in my router for the garmin ntp that will point it to a much closer ntp server. It automatically uploads weight stats to the app for easy tracking. Mine is set-up for only one user. But that has nothing to do with the scale. If you’re a Garmin user, the obvious choice for your smart scale… Setting up the scale, according to the instructions, was simple. Garmin Index is Wi-Fi connected, allowing you to wirelessly sync your data to Garmin Connect. It sounds better. It’s been over 4 years since Garmin released their first generation Index wifi-connected smart scale. Garmin Index WiFi Smart Scale In-Depth Review February 9, 2016 by DC Rainmaker | Garmin » Weight Scales | Comments (381) It’s been a few months since Garmin announced their Index WiFi Scale (at $149), so it’s time to dive in on an in-depth review and see how things have shaped up. At $150, it … I am unable to set up the scale. I couldn't figure out why the only way I could see my weight was through the app on my phone. I had this issue with my scale as well. In … No problem at al, works how it has to work. Thanks for the insight. Was it showing me KG? In its new avatar, the humble bathroom scale has become both smart and aesthetically pleasing. Associates there deserve One Hundred Stars Rating. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. Overall, the Withings Body Plus is the best smart scale. Been using it for a couple of months. If you’re a Garmin user, the obvious choice for your smart scale needs is the new Garmin Index S2. We use Garmin Connect a lot to track our exercise and sleep. Whilst I couldn’t trust the accuracy of any of the 4 devices I tested. As a competitive athlete I've owned numerous watches and bike computers, which are great. Reviewed in the United States on September 2, 2017. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Smart scale sync is a subscription service but it's cheap and hassle free. Readout shows weight as well as body fat, BMI, body water, and bone mass. This scale works great. I did have some WiFi connection issues but those were resolved when I added an access point/range extender in the room where the scale is. Comments (156) Garmin has just announced the new Index S2 smart WiFi scale, building slightly upon the previous first-generation Index WiFi scale released nearly 5 years ago. Much like the Body+ scale, the highlight of this smart scale is that the Garmin Index Scale is capable of measuring your body fat and water percentage as well as your muscle mass and bone mass… THUMBS UP IF YOU LIKE THIS VIDEO SUBSCRIBE NOW / Drop a comment below I hope you enjoyed this review of the Garmin Index Smart Scale! Having modern equipment like Garmin Index Smart Scale in your […] Lol. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. all recorded in the cloud with me not having to do anything beyond stepping onto the scale. Just saying... Kind of STUPID. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It said stones, lbs, kg. Couldn't get either to connect. Garmin Scale Review The simple bathroom scale that reveals the uncomfortable truth about your weight is getting a modern makeover. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Smart scales, however, enhance the health tracking experience by offering an easy way to track your weight, BMI, and other important body metrics. Whether you're training for a marathon or simply looking to lose a few pounds, effortlessly track your weight, body fat, bone density, water … Always wanted to get my data into Garmin. The Garmin Index S2 was the best of 4 relatively expensive smart scales I reviewed. Reviewed in the United States on September 18, 2018. Scale connected with Garmin App. When I stepped on it, it flashed some numbers that I just couldn't figure out, then went to bmi, muscle mass and do on. MFP seems to just hold the weight and none of the ancillary details like body fat, BMI, etc. Fitbit Aria 2 Smart Scale. I really couldn't find the settings via the app so I opened the pdf manual online. With a huge LCD display, they're the easiest to read and boast the most health data, including body water, muscular and skeletal mass measurements alongside the usual weight, body fat and BMI readouts. Everything else is consistent and that's good enough for me -- I'm not bothered if my % body fat is really 12% while the scale says it's 9.8%. Smart scales, however, enhance the health tracking experience by offering an easy way to track your weight, BMI, and other important body metrics. Which means I just paid 3x as much as a regular digital scale to manually enter the data STILL myself. I also have not had any issues with mine. (Like better body battery or vo2max? thanks for this, just subbed. Attempt connect. Measures weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat and water percentage, and muscle mass and bone mass. This new scale is a refresh to the uber-popular Garmin Index, which is now five years old. I was looking for settings when I found a switch on the bottom. Video review of the Garmin Index Scale. I have the Vivoactive 3 and Edge bike computer, the scales fit in beautifully. For basic measurements this scale works fine, but that is not why I paid so much money for a smart scale. But it is asinine that you even have to force a connect after the initial setup. ... so these scales report to the same Garmin Connect app. Oh well I thought. The process being, boot up app. Since I've done that it's been perfectly fine. Further, it can reveal more than just your body weight. In combination with my Fenix 5x and the scale, you have a true workout tracker. But will the Withings scale pass all that to MFP, so it can synch to Garmin Connect from there? It works as advertised. The Garmin Index Smart Scale wirelessly keeps track of your weight, body water, fat mass, and bone mass, but it's a bit pricey for what you get. Even tried at different wifi. I'm 100 % Satisfied Customer with Ann Arbor, Michigan Best Buy store, always go above and beyond my expectations. Does it make sense to wear the watch while cycling? And apparently they sold it back to Withings, but did that solve the issues or is it still no man's land? So for me it's now working as expected. Iâm tech-savvy so I could fix it as well. I like Garmin products (have their voice controlled dash cam and InReach GPSTracker/Iridium text communicator and love them both). Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. I weigh more than 16kg. Unlike what I read on review sites, its actually quite good! PROS Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and ANT+ syncing. When comparing to an InBody measurement, the percent body fat on the Garmin scale trends 1-2% high but it is consistent over time and I'd rather it show me a worst case scenario rather than get my confidence up by making me think my body fat is lower than it really is. Smart scales Garmin Index is intended for both professional athletes and for healthy lifestyle supporters. Step up to a healthier you with Garmin Index smart scale, the connected scale with metrics that matter. That said, the Garmin Index S2 was certainly the most believable and consistent. Mine works fine as well. Garmin Index Smart Scale (Bathroom Scale): 1 out of 5 stars from 2 genuine reviews on Australia's largest opinion site ProductReview.com.au. There was a firmware update back in November 2018 that seems to have fixed this issue (for me at least, in the UK). 1 year ago.